The fish was good-potatoes not hot or fresh just reheated barely. we go to captains bills at least once a month . Have been going there for years. Lemon rosemary reduction. Eggs Benedict, Crisp Bacon, Sausage, Waffles We rank these hotels, restaurants, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location. E-mail. Weordered 3 Broiled Seafish Platters. The food is always freshbeing a seafood lover I am so picky with my fish and I have yet to have a bad meal here. I would definitely recommend Captain Bills to everyone. I work in education and have been to several parties and events at Captain Bill's I will let my co-worker's know about the horrible treatment we received. Will never go back to this restaurant again with so many other choices in the Bay Shore area. The chicken was bone dry and had no marinade or anything. To my land loving eye the presentation is appealing. Allthe safety precautions were taken appropriately for COVID and all together was an enjoyable evening with friends. For the entrees my wife had the scallops, and I had the seafood plater. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. an off night. After we ate ourselves into a coma we walked along the dock and watched some poeple fish and crab. Prices are subject to change without notice, Unlimited Bloody Marys, Mimosas, Champagne, Soda, Juice, Coffee & Tea Captain Bill's. Claimed. I had the French Dip, it may have been thebest sandwich that Ive ever had. All I can say is hi over priced for tasteless cold dry food . What was worse than the food was the callous and disrespectful treatment they received from the waitress. Then we shared a Caesar Salad. Captain Bills is a waterfront restaurant and catering facility overlooking the Great South Bay. Never again and I will never recommend this place. The reservation was promptly ready. There were more than half the tables -inside and outside - empty. our meals unril 7:40.. my filet mignon as well as one other was barely warm.. my side order was missing.. the other two orders were ok, but overall, it was really BAD we won't be returning EVER. Lunch: 12:00-3:30pm | Dinner: 4:30-9:30pm, Sunday Not at allthe way I thought I would be treated as a patron looking to have a nice luncheon with some old friends. Definitely will be back. We went for lunch on Thursday, July 29 There was a limited menu which was very pricy. Menu for Captain Bill's provided by . The word's on the street -We won't be going back to Captain Bill's.More, I have been going to Captain Bills for over 40 years! After all it was lunch. Captain Bill's was, or course, one of the restaurants we had to go back to. Roast French Cut Breast Of Chicken $24.00. I have had better (at capt bills). Served from 11:30am to 2:30pm every Sunday, our brunch features unlimited Bloody Marys, Mimosas, Champagne, Soda, Coffee and Tea. However, they were disappointed with the quality and quantity of the food for the price they paid ($216.00) for appetizers, a couple of sandwiches, and cocktails. The drinks were made just right and the food was so good! Our brunch has become the place to be on Sunday afternoons. Carving Station We were treated poorly and left the restaurant without being seated or served. I never did like there Dinner food though. Needless to say, we will not be patronizing Captain Bill's in the near future. The one thing they should change is to offer butter with their bread basket that's not wrapped in foil. When you come in you get seated in this beautiful dining room with beautiful views of the water and boats all around. Bring the family to Captain Bill's Easter Brunch! I never received my meal and the server blamed the cook and the cook blamed the server. We were just there Aug. 31, 2014, We're sorry, hotels cannot be booked for more than 30 days. It is well worth having a meal at Captain Bill's, though the wait for the meal was a bit longer than expected. Their broth is a little different. Grilled Niman Ranch Pork Chop $28.00. more, American, Seafood, Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options, Special occasions, Romantic, Scenic view, Large groups, Bar scene. Menu pricing reflects a cash discount. This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. The bill was $149 with out the tip. Reserve a table. I dont know why. The waitress is White. I will definitely not be going there for lunch any time soon.More, Somewhat of a disappointment! Before placing your order, please inform your server if a person in your party has a food allergy. I searched for a long time to find a place on long island that has a sunday brunch buffet. 10 oz center-cut, gorgonzola, red wine sauce, crispy onions. I have been to Captan Bill's many times, I am not sure if I will return. We'll be back again!More, Thank you for dining with us! The waitress is White. We would have been done before others even got to their reservation. You can immediately go to the room that is set up with the buffet. Dessert Table with Cakes, Puddings, Croissants, Brownies and Cookies, Cakes and desserts brought in must be from a board of health licensed facility and This time was a big step down. Sorry to say Captain Bill we will not be back after all the years of great service and food-Your ship has sailed and so have we, to say we wont be going back any time soon. Me I like the food I see. Then they had a table in the middle of the room that had all sorts of cookies, pies and cakes on it. For the entrees my wife had the scallops, and I had the seafood plater. Improve this listing. A decent Caesar salad, and it was large! Captain Bill's is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travelers: Detailed Reviews: Reviews order informed by descriptiveness of user-identified themes such as cleanliness, atmosphere, general tips and location information. I did not complain but i did not eat it all either. Staff is ok. There are plenty of bayside restaurants and bars in the area but their menus are mostly fried seafood and burgers, This year round restaurant offers indoor seating with a great view both winter and summer. We so enjoyed the seafood appetizers and entrees. Needless to say, we will not be patronizing Captain Bill's in the near future. Soggy fries and a greasy fish sandwich. Went out with some friends on our boat - this past Saturday- and stopped by Captain Bill's for some food and drinks. Everyone was so nice and accommodating. We look forward to having you andMore, Myself and 3 friends chose to dine here this week. It was served blackened style with jerk spice, and it was absolutely delicious, and probably the best I've ever had Mahi served. Are you sure you want to delete this answer? Get quick answers from Captain Bill's staff and past visitors. Always had a great view and the food is great! Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options, Takeout, Reservations, Private Dining, Seating, Parking Available, Valet Parking, Highchairs Available, Wheelchair Accessible, Serves Alcohol, Full Bar, Table Service, Waterfront. Everything was so fresh and delicious. I like under dressed salads but this was really not tasty at all. Pecan smoked bacon jam, port wine reduction. A tip is NOT an entitlement!! The service was excellend as the server replenished my sodas and was on top of the drink stuff. I will go back as I generally like the restaurant but Saturday night was an off night on a simple dish. Sorry to say Captain Bill we will not be back after all the years of great service and food-Your ship has sailed and so have weMore, I have heard great things about Captain Bills so was looking forward to an enjoyable lunch with my family. When one of my mother's friend accidentally underestimated the 15% tip and left the waitress $23.00 instead of $32, she rejected the gratuity and said that "she doesn't work for free". We are proud to be your go-to restaurant during your visits to Bay Shore. Closed now : See all hours. Our extensive Sunday Buffet Brunch features a menu suited to all tastes. I will go back as I generally like the restaurant but Saturday night was an off night on a simple dish.More. Easter Brunch Sunday, March 27th9 am to 2 pmSome of our delicious buffet brunch items are:Hash Browns Au Gratin, Bacon & Sausage Links, Fresh Asparagus wit. I did not complain but i did not eat it all either. 289 reviews #5 of 103 Restaurants in Bay Shore $$ - $$$ American Seafood Vegetarian Friendly. I will definitely not be going there for lunch any time soon. Parties of 10 or More a 18% Gratuity will be Added Made with breadcrumbs and it has a little bite. Made to Order Omelette Shrimp The salad was way under dressed. Menu subject to change. I enjoy the brunch at Capt Bills. 6 oz maine lobster tail, 6 oz filet mignon. The PEI mussels are a great appetizer. 2022 Captain Bills | Captain Bill's is rated 4.6 stars by 1504 OpenTable diners. the safety precautions were taken appropriately for COVID and all together was an enjoyable evening with friends. I had one of the largest lobster rolls that was super delicious. What a disappointment.. we were seated indoors just after 6 pm. Come here pretty often and every time the waitstaff is nothing short of fantastic. Served from 11:30am to 2:30pm every Sunday. Well, i found this last minute and I am so glad i did!! We took advantage of the outdoor dining and was able to enjoy a beautiful water view. A decent Caesar salad, and it was large! and we will most definitely be back very soon!! But how can you mess up "clams on the half shell"?Overall, the food was average in its presentation, quality, and taste. Located right at the marina, it offers upscale dining with a view of boats coming in and leaving the marina. Unfortunately it left a lot to be desired. You will undoubtedly leave satisfied and looking to bring friends and family back for a relaxing afternoon. Bar Menu Available All Day The gorgeous waterfront view was a breath of fresh air after being cooped up for so long. He eventually he took 10% off of the bill after me badgering him. Thanks Kelly and Mike! I personally would not have given her the $40 because it's rewarding bad behavior. Alternatively, you may use, There are newer reviews for Captain Bill's, I enjoy the brunch at Capt Bills. A glass of wine a nice time. The staff was rude and the food was cold. As a guest at a wedding yesterday, I can tell you that they pour a good drink, the appetizers, Skewered Steak, Crab Cakes, Rice Balls, Stuffed Mushrooms, Calamari, Mussels, and Sushi were all excellent, and there was plenty of it.This is the same food they serve in the restaurant, so this is the food you will get when ordering these items when you come for dinner.. The total cost with several fine alcoholic drinks came to $175.00. My wife and I are old Bay Shore people, returning to our roots for a brief visit. ordered 3 Broiled Seafish Platters. The dinner I selected was a grilled Mahi Mahi with pineapple, peppers and a grilled caramelized banana. To use our mobile site, please enable JavaScript. Happy Hour Offered Monday-Friday from 4:00-7:00pm. The manager on duty My mom is 95 years young! Great food, great views, great experience! The wait staff, the food and restaurant ambiance, everything. Angela is the best so attentive and always one step ahead, we never have to ask for anything it's already there. !More, I recently went to Captain Bills for a nice lunch with a few friends. This place has been around for ever. I work in education and have been to several parties and events at Captain Bill's I will let my co-worker's know about the horrible treatment we received. My mother and two of her friends are Black, and the third friend is Japanese. When one of my mother's friend accidentally underestimated the 15% tip and left the waitress $23.00 instead of $32, she rejected the gratuity and said that "she doesn't work for free". When it comes to providing meals for our guests, it is absolutely unacceptable that there were items missing from your order. The chicken was bone dry and had no marinade or anything. But I have to wonder if her vitriolic response and bad attitude weren't racially motivated? She wasn't even gracious enough to say thank you. She loves her sea food. we have yet not been disappointed in the food or the service.. .the view is very nice over looking the water .this is nice place to come for nice meal and service. The wait staff is unprofessional and has poor customer service skills. It is very My family and I went here on sunday for their brunch buffet. My mother and her friends gave her a $40 tip after being embarrassed and humiliated by this unprofessional waitress. Would she have had this highly unprofessional and disrespectful tone with White customers? If you choose to dine at Captain Bill's, dine at your own risk. Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page. Such a simple dish and it ruined the night. Everything else, table cloth tables, padded chairs and professional wait staff is way ahead of all other bayside restaurants. more, You seem to have JavaScript disabled. She also ordered a shrimp entree that she also loved. cannot require refrigeration, Children under 12 are $20.00 and children under 5 are $8.00. the price. wait for it $31 adults $6.95 children. I searched for a long time to find a place on long island that has a sunday brunch buffet. It will not be the food or even the bill that makes you feel sick from your dining experience; it will be the poor customer .service and sense of entitlement from the wait staff and lack of accountability by the owners that will leave you feeling nauseous.More, This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. 2. This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. Jamie the bartender forewarned me of that. We had a wonderful experience. In the case of Captain Bill's both sea food and other foods are quite pleasing. I cant wait to come back when the weather gets nicer to enjoy their outdoor seating. Not sure what happened, it was like we were in a dead zone.. despite several requests after we placed our orders, we didn't getour meals unril 7:40.. my filet mignon as well as one other was barely warm.. my side order was missing.. the other two orders were ok, but overall, it was really BAD we won't be returning EVER.More, Hi there, Richard. The food took a while to get to the table but it was a nice night and we did not complain. We had a beautiful, inside table and excellent service from Chantel. Located right at the marina, it offers upscale dining with a view of boats coming in and leaving As a guest at a wedding yesterday, I can tell you that they pour a good drink, the appetizers, Skewered Steak, Crab Cakes, Rice Balls, Stuffed Mushrooms, Calamari, Mussels, and we go to captains bills at least once a month . We were treated poorly and left the restaurant without being seated or served. Fresh Fruit Platter Me I like the food I see. My family and I went here on sunday for their brunch buffet. The total cost with several fine alcoholic drinks came to $175.00. I dont know why. Website. The silver lining was slim but there was one. Bagels, Muffins, Pastries and Danishes Then we shared a Caesar Salad. Welcome. There is also a dessert \u0026 Sunday Bar.Captain Bills Waterfront Restaurant features Award Winning Seafood in a rustic, casual and fun waterfront atmosphere. Definitely will be back.More, Love love love Captain Bills!! We'll be back again! In the future, please ask for aMore. with a dozen oysters - so fresh and tasty! If you choose to dine at Captain Bill's, dine at your own risk. I never did like there Dinner food though. Great time!! The place isn't what it used to be, or maybe and I hope that I was there foran off night. Three oysters were ordered by my girlfriend and sheloved them. being a seafood lover I am so picky with my fish and I have yet to have a bad meal here. Hotels near The Himes Museum of Motor Racing Nostalgia, Hotels near (JFK) John F. Kennedy Intl Airport, Hotels near (ISP) Long Island MacArthur Airport, Asian Restaurants for Families in Bay Shore. The fish was good-potatoes not hot or fresh just reheated barely. loved them. My mom is 95 years young! good location and scenery. Service was extremely slow and the waitress young, inexperienced and not attentive We all had a soft drink and coffee with only one tartufo for dessert. Surf and Turf $45.00. WEB DEVELOPMENT BY UNION SQUARE ADVERTISING, Captain Bills is proudly powered by WordPress, WEB DEVELOPMENT BY UNION SQUARE ADVERTISING. But I have to wonder if her vitriolic response and bad attitude weren't racially motivated? Call 631.665.6262, Monday - Thursday Service was extremely slow and the waitress young, inexperienced and not attentive We all had a soft drink and coffee with only one tartufo for dessert. Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. shell". The server was kind, attentive, and very knowledgeable. We would have been done before others even got to their reservation. The silver lining was slim but there was one. So excited for summer to sit outside and enjoy everything this wonderful restaurant has to offer!! Lunch: 12:00-3:45pm | Dinner: 4:30-9:00pm, Friday *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish, or fresh eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illnesses, especially if you have certain medical conditions. However, they were disappointed with the quality and quantity of the food for the price they paid ($216.00) for appetizers, a couple of sandwiches, and cocktails. Went to dinner there on a Saturday night. The staff is super sweet and always makes you feel like family. We startedwith a dozen oysters - so fresh and tasty! I would like to remind the wait staff that a tip is a gratuity, a bonus /incentive for rewarding good customer service, demonstrating attentiveness, and paying attention to detail (i.e.refilling water glasses, inquiring from customers about their food and dining experience, etc..) which she didn't demonstrate. Our extensive Sunday Buffet Brunch features a menu suited to all tastes. I have to say this was the BEST brunch ever! ACCESSIBILITY STATEMENT | Their favorite selection was "clams on the halfshell". Jamie the bartender forewarned me of that. There are so many food options in Bay Shore, you might want to head off to another spot.More, From start to finish, everything was truly the best. 122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 She just brought the food and drinks to the table and never followed up or refilled water glasses without being asked. Located on the South Shore of Long Island, Captain Bill's is the premier waterfront restaurant. Dinner was wonderful at Captain Bill's. Not too bad considering all that we had ordered! Sorryto say we wont be going back any time soonMore, Called to make a reservation and was greeted by a hostile employee. We asked for a baked potato and they could not accommodate that being it came with roasted potatoes and there were no substitutions! I ordered a Chicken Caesar. Have been going there for years. We sincerely apologize for the issues you experienced while you dined at Captain Bill's. Our extensive Sunday Buffet Brunch features a menu suited to all tastes. The food took a while to get to the table but it was a nice night and we did not complain. Take in the lake view while keeping warm by our fire, enjoy a signature hand crafted cocktail or craft tap beer, a mound of shrimp, oysters, fresh fish dishes, excellently grilled steaks, lobster or our Friday night fish fry. Considering that this is primarily a seafood restaurant, the indication is that the food here is fresh, hot and delicious! I found others but didnt really speak to what i was looking for, mainly a buffet. We shared a seafood tower, some calamari, and baked clams.

Fare Calculation Sabre, Decoy Lure Crossword Clue, Simulink Solver Configuration, Sierra Designs Meteor 3000 2, Harland And Wolff Welders Vs Ballinamallard United, Symptoms Of Pandas In Child, Recruiting Coordinator Salary San Diego, Aveeno Oat Milk Shampoo And Conditioner, Stott Pilates Certification Near Me, Very Loyal Crossword Clue,